James Cook III or Jonathan Taylor: Who to Start in Week 11
Fantasy football comparison · RB · BUF vs RB · IND
Updated
Start Jonathan Taylor. He projects 17.0 points this week versus 16.8 for James Cook III.
James Cook III
RB · BUF
- Weekly projection / EV
- 16.8
- Rest-of-season value
- 134.3 points
Jonathan Taylor
RB · IND
- Weekly projection / EV
- 17.0
- Rest-of-season value
- 119.0 points
The comparison
Weekly decision: Lean Jonathan Taylor on projected points: 17.0 versus 16.8 for James Cook III, a 0.2-point edge. EV is an expectation, not a guaranteed floor; check current availability before setting your lineup.
Rest of season: James Cook III leads Jonathan Taylor by 15.3 projected points over the rest of the season (134.3 versus 119.0). That is longer-term value, not this week's ceiling.
Explore the full fantasy rankings, each James Cook III outlook and Jonathan Taylor outlook, compare any two players in Start/Sit, or use the trade analyzer.